Crammed Train Thoughts

So I’m crammed on a train between Birmingham and the South West. It seems the train lines’ solution to PM Andy Burnham freezing train fares is to shove as many humans into a three hour long train journey as you’d expect to see on the Tokyo Subway.

So in the interest of keeping myself sane, I chucked on the now rather old A View From The Veranda Podcast, from Henry Hyde and Neil Shuck.

https://meeples.wordpress.com/view-from-the-veranda/

Episode 2, one of my favourites, is to do with the morality of wargaming, and likely why I found the discussion around Midwinter Mini’s infamous Bolt Action video rather strange.

I was already well aware of the discussions within wargaming circles of the morality of playing certain periods of history and certain armies, with even the great Henry Hyde expressing discomfort with SS units on the table, or gaming more recently than WW2.

But that’s not really the point that jumped into my brain as I tried to manoeuvre my leg in such a way that let blood go back into it, though I am still fascinated by the Midwinter drama all these years on. I loved his discussion with Pleasant Kenobi on such matters:

Neil and Henry in the podcast discussed how Germans were the best selling range for any company selling WW2 figures, and their suspicion was that they simply looked the best. I think that’s a fair point, aesthetically German gear does tend to look best, it was a big part of their propaganda machine. I’d like to add a secondary component to their sales figures, and that’s a slight morbid curiosity. The similar urge to watch a good horror film, probably lends itself to collecting a WW2 German army.

But neither are my main point. In the final analysis, I believe the reason Germans sell best is actually blindingly obvious, and has nothing really to do with the above two points. Simply put, they are the main Axis power. For Allies you have three main options, British and Commonwealth, Americans and Soviets, for the Axis you have Germans, the Japanese (in very specific theatres) and then the Italians. So while the go to Ally may split gamers based on preference, the go to Axis seems set for me.

So for the majority of gamers, I imagine the Germans will either be the first or second force that they collect.

Thoughts?

One thought on “Crammed Train Thoughts”

  1. ‘Cause they were there lad. There would not be much point collecting JUST the Allies. As for why they outstrip the others in popularity, yes they had snazzy uniforms and they fought well. Their emphasis on junior officer initiative in combat (something which runs counter to the usual stereotype of a totalitarian country) was one helpful aspect. In the end they were overwhelmed by having too many countries to fight and too much hardware, notably air power, from America. American vehicles and supplies poured into Russia as well as Britain and other friendly forces.

    One fascinating aspect its the persistence of the German helmet. It continued to be used, after the war, in South American forces. Also, when the Americans updated their uniforms and helmets in the 80s the computer came up with a helmet very similar to what was worn by the Third Reich. That is because it gave the best protection to the wearer.

Leave a Reply